David Stevens

Confucius › Questions

Did Confucius invent the golden rule?

The sentence is in the Analects. Whether it is the heart of his teaching is another matter.

Where it is

Do not do unto others what thou wouldst not have done to thee. It appears in the Analects when a student, Zigong, asks for a single word to live by, and again inside a longer answer to another student. Zigong produces it himself, unprompted, in a third passage, and is told it is beyond him.

The one thread

The complication is a famous scene. Confucius says there is one single thread binding his way together, says so to a student by name, and leaves the room. The others turn on the young man and ask what he meant, and the answer they get, faithfulness and fellow-feeling, is the student's, not the Master's.

It has been the received answer for two and a half thousand years, and it is a gloss.

The doubt

The golden-rule passages do not behave like the teaching around them. The rest of the book is worked through particular men in particular difficulties. These few passages state a portable principle. One specialist treats them as later insertions on those grounds. Most scholars do not go that far.

There is a broader caution. The word at the centre of his teaching, ren, is generally held not to reduce to a rule at all: caring for others, from an understanding of how things look where they are standing, shown in conduct rather than defined in sentences.

More about Confucius

Something to read first

The trial file

A short piece, free: what the documents in Galileo’s own trial file actually say, including the two pages that decided it. It isn’t sold anywhere, and it’s the fastest way to see how these books are built.

One email when there’s a new book. Nothing else, and you can leave any time.